How a Second Chance Question Can Make Us Better Moms

by Kat on May 17, 2012

The following post is from Kat of Inspired To Action:

Source: Alyssa L. Miller

A few months ago I stumbled upon a phrase that has saved my sanity. A phrase that single handedly reduced the amount of bickering in my home. A phrase that frees me from mommy guilt and shines the hallowed light of wisdom on the hearts and minds of my children. A phrase that shall go down in history…

“Kat…will you stop with the melodrama and get on with this magical little phrase of yours…?”

Oh, yeah, right…

The phrase is… {drumroll} “What could you have done differently?”

Perhaps you were hoping for something a bit more profound? No worries, let me show you how powerful these words are.

Second Chance Scenario 1

My kids are playing outside. My son and youngest daughter are fighting over a scooter. It’s my son’s scooter, but my daughter was already playing with it when my son walked over, pushed her off and tried to take it. They both come running into the house upset and telling their sides of the story.

This is all completely hypothetical…of course.

Formerly, my response would have been:
1. Calm them down.
2. Ask what happened.
3. Ask them to stop talking at the same time.
4. Calm them down, again.
5. Ask one kid what happened.
6. Listen while kid #2 hops around desperate to tell their side of the story.
7. Decide who should have the scooter.
8. Listen to protests.
9. Send them back out to play, operating on a very weak truce.

Now, I simply say:
1. “I see you are upset with one another. What could you have done differently?”
2. Then, I listen as each of them comes up with the exact answer I would have previously given to them in lecture form.
3. Then I say, “Great answer! You really know how to handle the situation. Now go do that.”

Honestly? It’s like magic. Even my 4 year old knows where he’s gone wrong, and how he could do things differently. And since the question is entirely self focused, my children spend their brainpower fixing what is actually in their power to fix, instead of blaming or trying to control one another.

I know it almost sounds “too simple” to work, but trust me and try it. It’s kind of awesome.

Second Chance Scenario 2

I am a wreck. It’s the end of the day and the kids are finally in bed. I was grumpy, impatient, grumpy, annoyed, grumpy, tired, grumpy, frustrated and…grumpy.

Closing the doors to their rooms after kissing them goodnight was akin to dragging myself across the finish line of a 100 mile ultra marathon. Except harder.

I could have lamented about how miserable I was at being a mom. I could have listed all the things I did wrong. I could have berated myself for not living up to my ideals.

Instead? I asked myself a simple question, “What could I have done differently?”

After I’ve sufficiently answered, I continue the conversation with myself, “Great! Now go do that tomorrow.”

When I ask that question, I know that those thoughts are the only ones that matter. I am better able to recognize guilt, condemnation and other unhelpful thoughts and replace them with positive actions I can take the next day.

The Power of Second Chances

Training our children isn’t about simply punishing wrong responses. It’s even more importantly about giving second chances and teaching them the right responses.

When we ask them “what they could have done differently?” we are giving them the gift of a “do over.” We are saying that we believe in them and their ability to do the right thing.

Could you give yourself or those around you more second chances? What are the “phrases” that have helped you as a mom?

Kat blogs at Inspired To Action, a site dedicated to helping moms develop the habits and skills they need to effectively manage their homes and raise children who are prepared to change the world. Kat loves music, running, technology, Jesus and Tex-Mex food. Not necessarily in that order.

  • http://twitter.com/life_edited Amanda Williams

    I love this! It is indeed simple but SO helpful. And honestly? I love simple. I neeeeeed simple. So thank you. 

    • http://www.inspiredtoaction.com/ Kat @ Inspired To Action

      Amanda…me too!

  • Parthenia Fayne

    Love it! I have used that with my children a FEW times. This is a great reminder and encouragement to make that the norm. You are so right. It is funny to watch their faces when they are asked to think. It is awesome to watch my stress diminish when I don’t feel pressured to solve their problems AND watch them learn how to work through their problems themselves. Then, I get to give God all the credit (where it is so well-deserved). It’s also great to ask that of myself and move on…trusting God and giving Him the credit. Now that’s being anxious for nothing. AWESOME!! By the way, your writing style…hilarious!! I especially loved the correct usage of the adjective “grumpy”!!!

    • http://www.inspiredtoaction.com/ Kat @ Inspired To Action

      Well thank you Parthenia!!

  • Sara P.

    I have a sweet girl who is almost four. Every time I discipline her I ask “do you know what you did wrong?”. And every time she just answers “I don’t know”, even if it was straight forward stuff like hitting her sister. I love your idea of getting them to work through it on their own, but if she refuses to recognize even what she did wrong, I doubt she would offer a solution to a problem on her own.. Any ideas how I could get through to her, I don’t want to “punish her into confession”? I do think she knows what she did wrong, she will say sorry and admit it when I verbalize it for her.

    Thank you Kat by the way for your faithfulness to the Lord, I’ve been reading your blog for a few months and I’m doing Hello Mornings now for the first time and the Lord has used both to bless me and grow me so much in motherhood and in him.  :)

    • http://www.inspiredtoaction.com/ Kat @ Inspired To Action

      Sara,
      Great question! 

      If she is able to verbalize her thoughts then a good tactic is to use what Amy McCready from positiveparentingsolutions.com refers to as the “When – Then” so (using my fictional situation above) you could say something like, “When you’re able to tell me what you could have done differently, then you can continue playing outside.” 

      If she truly does comprehend what happened, then she’ll likely think of an answer relatively quickly. 

      Thank you so much for your encouragement! It’s so fantastic to hear what God is doing in your life!

  • kristin delooff

    Thanks so much; Kat!  Really helpful–I will share this.

    • http://www.inspiredtoaction.com/ Kat @ Inspired To Action

      Kristin,
      I’m so glad you’ve found it helpful! Thanks for sharing!

  • Ursula Liao

    Kat! This post ministers to me MUCH!!! THANK YOU!!!! I will pin this post to share the wealth. :)   I’ve been following you for awhile but don’t comment much – I want you to know that I truly appreciate your assist in inspiring us TO ACTION through your posts in following, enjoying and knowing the Lord more. Thank you. :)

    • http://www.inspiredtoaction.com/ Kat @ Inspired To Action

      Ursula,
      Thank you so much for your sweet encouragement!

  • Krys

    Thanks for this great insight, Kat!  I only have one child, and so my opportunities to solve these kinds of situations will likely be limited, but I simply adore the concept of second chances.  Anytime I have to discipline my daughter, I let her know that she will have another chance to do things right the next time or the next day.

    For example, she is allowed just a teensy bit of a movie each night as a reward for getting into her pajamas and brushing her teeth before bed.  If she puts up a fight or fusses about either of those things, she gets no reward.  But, I always let her know that there is another opportunity to do it right the next night, while standing firm in saying “no, you can’t just watch some of the movie tonight anyway”.

    I also very much appreciate the concept of giving myself a second chance.  I’m more apt to criticize myself than give myself an opportunity to review how I’ll do better next time.  Excellent advice!

    Thanks again!

    • http://www.inspiredtoaction.com/ Kat @ Inspired To Action

      Krys,
      We moms can be so hard on ourselves, can’t we? Hopefully, there will be a few more moms giving themselves second chances tomorrow!

  • Kate

    This is so great! Thanks for sharing!

    • http://www.inspiredtoaction.com/ Kat @ Inspired To Action

      You’re welcome Kate!

  • http://joyceandnorm.wordpress.com Joyce and Norm

    I love this, Kat! I’ll let you know how it goes. :)

  • http://naturalmomstalkradio.com/blog carrielee

    I love this post because I do this same thing with my kids and myself! When there is a squabble, instead of trying to figure out “whodunit”, (because it’s almost always that they *both* chose to act in appropriately), I ask them the question. It’s great because it puts the power back into their hands.

    When I’ve had a bad day, I often “reverse engineer” it to figure out what went wrong (usually, several things triggered it), and I can always learn from the experience.

  • Bellisfamily2010

    Totally works :) After asking this question to any combonation of my 4 young boys, they always grin once they realize that they have responded with what I would have said! Great advice for any moms who havent tried it… go for it!

  • Pingback: How a Second Chance Question Can Make Us Better Moms — Inspired To Action

  • Tiffany

    This is fantastic. Thank you for this post.  

  • http://www.structureinanunstructuredlife.com/ Beth

    Great post – thank you! I love that this is something I can start doing right now! Such a simple concept that once I read it, I thought, “Duh, why I haven’t I been doing this before?” But sometimes the simplest solutions are the most overlooked! Thanks for shining light on this great idea!

  • shannon williams

    I have three girls, 15, 13, and 9.  Bickering between the oldest and youngest has been at an all time high the past few weeks.  (The middlest is the peacemaker of the three.)  JUST LAST NIGHT I was Googling solutions for bickering kids. I am definitely going to try this approach!!

  • Thelindells

    Kat,
    These sound so similar to our home. I’ve recently been doing a similar version as you’ve shared. Often they still need to process and tell their story so as a way to try to encourage self-responsibility for their actions we ask them, “What was your part? What did YOU do”? Not just tattling about what their sibling had done wrong. Just thought someone else may benefit too. Blessings all,
    Chrystal

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=616239196 Alexis Richter

    I needed to see this today (we had a horrible bedtime last night that went well past 11 PM). Thank you so much for sharing. I am going to put this into action today, with my boys and myself. 

  • Kimberly

    This is something I often do with my 2 kids.  But, giving myself “permission” to ask the same of myself is going to incredible! Thanks for adding that simple paragraph…I can be so critical of myself it never dawned on me to practice being as kind to myself as I am with the kids!

  • Karin

    Kat, thank you so much! I love this almost more for myself (to use on me) than using it on my kids. I love the fact that this question focuses me on the future, on the do-over, on the next time I get to get it right, instead of looking back and playing the tape over and over of what happened and how bad it was.

  • http://www.Phyllis-Sather.com/ Phyllis

    It continually amazes me how simple the Lord’s ideas are. Now if I can just begin to make this a habit…

  • Jennifer

    I love this idea.  I can hardly wait to use it with my son (4 yrs old).  I’m sure I will have a chance at least once today ;)  Something I have started also doing with my son is when he is melting down, I don’t put him into timeout exactly, but I send him to his room, with the door wide open and I tell him that he is allowed to come out when he is calm.  And after a few times of this, I noticed that he has started doing it for himself.  Sometimes it is to try to get out of doing something that I have asked him to do, but I have also found that once he has pulled himself together, he is also much more agreeable about doing whatever I had asked him to do before he put himself in his room.

  • Leslie

    Thanks for sharing Kat. Arguing is a big issue in our house right now. I’m laughing as a I realize that exact scooter scenario has taken place on more than one occasion. I’ll try this. Hoping that the 3-yr-old can grasp it…

  • phoward336

    Excellent advice Kat.  I do this for my kids, but GENIUS for doing it for myself!

  • Pingback: Weekend Reads 5.20.12 | Not Just Cute

  • http://www.facebook.com/stacy.buck78 Stacy Buck

    Kat, this is brilliant!  I am going to share this today with how this experimental question played out in my home today at http://www.inthetrenches.com and our Facebook page.  Keep doing the great and inspiring work – I am so blessed since “following” you on this blog.  Did I tell you I want a mom cave and I have some great ideas how to make that happen??  Thanks again for inspiring me to action! Be Great. Stacy Buck

  • Danastege

    So simple but so necessary as my son is currently getting out of bed for the umpteenth time. Sometimes we all need a reminder. Thanks for sharing. 
    http://www.homemadebest.wordpress.com

  • Guest from across the pond

    Kat, thank you for this. I so need to hear it.
    And by the way, there’s a word for ‘second chance’… it’s call GRACE. GRACE give us a chance to do over… Hurray!

  • Idontdoplastic

    OH MY GOSH! thank you thank you thank you! my normal approach is the same as your “old” approach. this has been miraculous!  i thought i would give it a try just to see….unbelievable. truly. i’m nearly speechless just thinking about what that question has to done around here. thank you !

  • Maggie Macaulay

    Thanks for the terrific post, and there will be a link to you blog in the May 29th issue of Parenting News, our free weekly newsletter for parents and teachers. I hope it brings you many readers! It is terrific to teach children to ask one another how they would do it differently the next time, and  when my teenage daughter and I have disagreements, we ask, “How can we handle this differently the next time?”.  The concept of a ‘do over’ is great on so many levels – that we make mistakes and learn from them, that we can change our perspective and do things more lovingly, that we can practice doing it the way we desire, and that there are more chances in life to do things the way we prefer.  All good!

    Thanks!
    Maggie Macaulay, MS Ed
    http://www.WholeHeartedParenting.com

  • http://themommybanks.wordpress.com/ Candice

    Love this!  

  • Pingback: Things to Write Home About – 5/20/12

Previous post:

Next post: